Response from PFLAG New Orleans

On January 10, 2000, after six years of writing letters via both postal mail and email to PFLAG New Orleans about queer by choice issues without receiving one single reply, Frank Aqueno finally received the following reply from PFLAG New Orleans.

——- Original Message ——-
From: PFLAG New Orleans
To: Frank Aqueno
Sent: Monday, January 10, 2000 4:33 AM
Subject: PFLAG New Orleans

Dear Mr. Aqueno:

    The Board of Directors of the New Orleans Area Chapter of
Parents, Families, and Friends of Lesbians and Gays takes this opportunity to
respond to correspondence you recently attempted to send us.

    It is our understanding that you believe we have an obligation and a duty
to present positions other than the position that there is a biological basis
for sexual orientation.  It is also our understanding that you believe our
chapter is not fulfilling PFLAG’s Mission Statement unless other views are presented.

    We believe our chapter fulfills the PFLAG Mission Statement and promotes
the health and well-being of gays, lesbians, bisexuals, and transgendered
persons, and their families and friends through support, education and
advocacy.  While we acknowledge that some individuals and groups may have
beliefs different from those we espouse, we believe that an individual's
sexual orientation is a product of biology.  We recognize that people can
choose to engage in sexual acts that are contrary to their sexual
orientation. Gay people can choose to have heterosexual sex and heterosexual
people can choose to have homosexual sex.  While choices related to behaviors
may be influenced by sexual orientation, these choices are not dictated by
it. While behaviors may be subject to choice, we do not believe that one's
sexual orientation is matter of choice.

    While we disagree with your belief that sexual orientation is a matter of
choice, we readily provide support for GLBT people regardless of their
personal beliefs regarding the causes of their sexual orientation.  We also
acknowledge that some individuals may not wish to associate with groups who
hold beliefs which are contrary to their own.  We honor their right to
associate with and organize groups which espouse different beliefs. We also
honor their right to present their views via more public forums;  however, we
do not think we have an obligation to provide a forum for any individual or
group to espouse their contrary beliefs at PFLAG sponsored functions.

    If you believe that we have misunderstood your position and
believe that additional communications are needed, it would be helpful if you
would  more specifically outline your concerns, provide your suggestions for
ameliorating your concerns, and explain how your suggestion favorably impacts
our ability to fulfill our mission.

    Please note that the e-mail address listed in your original communication
as the address for the local chapter was erroneous. We received a copy via our
national office rather than through our chapter's e-mail address.  Responses
to this letter may be sent to the mailing address captioned on our letterhead
or to our correct e-mail address.

   A copy of this letter is being sent by mail as a courtesy to ensure that
you have a copy available for your personal files.

                    Sincerely,
                    The Board of Directors of the New Orleans Area Chapter of PFLAG

    PS Please note the address below for both the mail and electronic
communication with the chapter.

        New Orleans Area Chapter of
        Parents, Family and Friends of Lesbians and Gays
        P O Box 15515
        New Orleans, LA  70175

        Website: http://pflagnola.homepage.com
        E-mail:    pflagno@aol.com

After six years of ignoring Frank's letters which he sent via postal mail and by email to both the chapter email address and to the individual email addresses of the members of the PFLAG New Orleans Board of Directors, the chapter's only excuse was that he got one email address wrong on one of his letters, which they still received via the national office anyway.

And let's examine their claim that they "readily provide support for GLBT people regardless of their personal beliefs regarding the causes of their sexual orientation." What does it mean to "provide support"? What rights constitute "gay rights"?

It is our belief that fighting for "gay rights" includes fighting for the right of gay or queer people to form our own opinions about the causes of sexual orientation. The right to form our own opinions is probably the most basic and essential of all human rights. And in conjunction with that, it is our belief that to "provide support" to lesbian, gay, transgendered and bisexual people means to support that basic human right—including support for our attempts to express our opinions and experiences of choice to our family members.

Any chapter that promotes the belief "that an individual's sexual orientation is a product of biology" and/or "that one's sexual orientation is matter of choice" and refuses to provide equal support to other opinions held by members of the lesbian, gay, transgendered and bisexual community is not supporting but rather interfering with our attempts to express our own opinions and experiences of choice. Such a chapter provides support only to the members of the lesbian, gay, transgendered and bisexual community who are willing to let the chapter decide for us what it wishes to tell our parents about our sexual orientations. This form of "support" shows absolutely no respect for our most basic human right to form our own opinions, and definitely does not fulfill PFLAG's mission of supporting the human rights of lesbian, gay, transgendered and bisexual people.

Back to PFLAG: Building a Safe Environment for Our Parents to Learn About Our Choices
Back to the QueerByChoice.com Homepage

© 2000-2009 by Gayle Madwin except where otherwise noted. All rights reserved.